Does Hollywood Really Need Another Pirates of the Caribbean?

adminSeptember 6, 2021

Does Hollywood Really Need Another Pirates of the Caribbean?

pirates of the Caribbean It seems likely that it will receive a reboot or direct sequel in the next few years, but is it necessary for the franchise to continue in any form or should the series simply be allowed to end? Released in 2003, The Curse of the Black Pearl it was a surprise success for director Gore Verbinski. With a cheesy central twist from Johnny Depp, a strange genre-mix tone that included horror, comedy, and adventure, and a dark origin (a Disneyland ride of the same name), pirates of the Caribbean It hardly seemed like major franchise stuff.

Indeed, Verbinski’s later failure The Lone Ranger proved that the exact ingredients described above could result in costly and misjudged insanity. The strange launch of the series, along with the then recent failure of Cutthroat Island, it is not surprising that many industry experts predicted The Curse of the Black Pearl It would be an independent disappointment. However the pirates of the Caribbean Instead, the franchise proved to be a huge success and spawned a series of sequels so flawed that the failure of the original film may have been preferable.

Related: Why Pirates of the Caribbean Captain Teague Was a Mistake

First pirates of the Caribbean The sequels retained Verbinski as their director and held on to some of the charm of the original, but failed to regain its magic, while subsequent outings were outright failures. Despite this, another installment of the profitable Disney franchise is even more inevitable after Jungle cruise could not replace the pirates of the Caribbean series at the box office. The question of money aside (as studios rarely do), the question of whether Hollywood really needs another pirates of the Caribbean, or whether the franchise should be allowed to end gracefully, it’s worth questioning.

The original Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy was divisive

Will Turner stabs Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean at World's End

Autonomous, tonally messy, and surprisingly tragic at times, Verbinski’s original trilogy did not stick to the summery blockbuster tone set in the first film and, as a result, lost the approval of many critics. However, despite the countless failures of the second and third pirates of the Caribbean movies, contain interesting half-formed ideas and compelling fictional creations, even though their tradition doesn’t quite square. The frame hole mounted At the end of the world It’s particularly easy to tear apart, but the trilogy’s closer tries to make something truly original with the material and ends a franchise that started out as a swashbuckling action comedy with a shockingly tragic romantic coda.

The one directed by Verbinski pirates of the Caribbean The sequels are not, as some overzealous fans may claim, misunderstood classics, and they also can’t compare to the quick wit and deft action of The Curse of the Black Pearl. However, they are dramatic, compelling, and packed with ideas (possibly too many to contain at their runtime). The admirable attempt to tell a complicated story throughout the franchise’s numerous installments foreshadowed the MCU’s more well-structured later experiments, and Verbinski’s ambition was praised by some critics. However, once Verbinski chose not to direct the subsequent sequels, the pirates of the Caribbean the franchise lost its way in a more significant sense.

The subsequent sequels of Pirates of the Caribbean were analyzed

Kaya Scodelario as Carina Smyth and Johnny Depp as Captain Jack Sparrow in Pirates of the Caribbean Dead Men Tell No Tales

The fourth and fifth pirates of the Caribbean movies were less divisive, but only insofar as they were universally unpleasant. Few critics defended the fourth exit, On Stranger Tides, and almost none had kind words for the fifth, Dead men tell no tales, with many claiming the franchise was dead long before Disney sent Depp’s Jack Sparrow packing due to the star’s legal troubles. However, despite its critical flaw, it is important to note that On Stranger Tides employed reliable and successful box office director Rob Marshall while Dead men tell no tales introduced Javier Bardem to the cast, which means there was no shortage of new talent injected into the sick series.

Related: Jungle Cruise’s Best Twist Comes From Pirates of the Caribbean

Some have argued that the proposal starring Margot Robbie pirates of the Caribbean Rebooting could save the series, but the pedigree of actors and directors involved in previous failed sequels shows that the franchise needs more than fresh blood to get it going again. Both bringing back the original director and recruiting new talent have failed in the pirates of the Caribbean series so far, which makes the prospect of a reboot less exciting.

Pirates of the Caribbean may not work as a reboot

Margot Robbie Pirates of the Caribbean queer character Jack sparrow

A reboot that reintroduces the world of pirates of the Caribbean The series through new eyes could work if the new movie makes a clear break and is definitely different from the original movies. However, if the pirates of the Caribbean the franchise needs to leave its recurring characters, supporting cast, and lore just to function, so there is little left to do so pirates of the Caribbean, and the reboot for all intents and purposes can also be a new disconnected property. Some would say that this is exactly what Disney tried with the suspiciously similar Jungle cruise (with its historical period, exotic setting, elements of supernatural fantasy, and hybrid elements of action, comedy, and horror), but no new series is likely to have the impact that the years have already established. pirates of the Caribbean would be: impact that would improve when viewers found out that the reboot is a name-only follow-up.

Why a direct sequel to Pirates of the Caribbean is a bad idea

Pirates of the caribbean dead man's chest jack sparrow william turner elizabeth swan

Without the return of Jack Sparrow from Depp, the pirates of the Caribbean The franchise has lost its main appeal. The series could try to continue, but the public is unlikely to be interested in pirates of the Caribbean sans Sparrow, as the character is tied to the interest most fans have in the franchise. Despite Depp’s over-reliance on subsequent sequels, the character’s essence is what made the original The Curse of the Black Pearl an outstanding success and what sets it apart from all subsequent sequels.

The free combination of comedy, threat and charm embodied by Jack Sparrow was reflected in the shifting tone of the original film, where Verbinski’s sequels settled into darker territory and later installments were content to row into more purely comic territory. . As evidenced by the low performance of Suicide squad, Robbie doesn’t have the same unique audience appeal as Depp and a reboot of the pirates of the Caribbean The series starring the actor is likely to end up being seen as an imitation rather than a legitimate continuation precisely because of Depp’s absence. Ultimately, the appeal of the pirates of the Caribbean is inextricably linked to the character of Jack Sparrow, making a successful sequel nearly impossible, although that has never stopped Hollywood before.

More: Why the road to El Dorado was bombed in 2000 (but it’s wanted now)

Jason Momoa Aquaman 2 Lost Kingdom new costume

Aquaman 2’s first images reveal a very different superhero costume

About the Author


Good Movies to Watch


Leave a comment

Name *
Add a display name
Email *
Your email address will not be published